• Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 8:34 p.m.

    Well done for finding the shadows. Have you tried a much darker and/or a B&W version?
    For my taste, these do not stand out as shadows, and could be little piles of sawdust on a field, which I think a much darker version could improve.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:02 p.m.

    The Victorian engineering shown here is wonderfully visible. No electric parts and mysteries hidden in a box, but all there to be seen and to be understood relatively easily by anyone interested or those having to work with it. The iron gears, with their dribbles of paint and touches of rust, have a no-nonsense, robust appearance.
    A shout-out to the little brick huts too!
    The four views are well-chosen and nicely composed, each one adding a bit more information, but without repeating the look of the previous ones, which keeps the interest and anticipation going.
    An excellent series.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:14 p.m.

    Although the boat is similar to last week's, the composition is very different and, I think, better.
    The way the bamboo hangs low over the boats in a protective way is attractive. We mainly take in the lines of the bamboo stems, not the leaves.
    Then the same bamboo is reflected in the water, but this time it is the leaves which dominate. Somehow this gives the effect of the boat being suspended slightly above the reflected sky!
    The result can be described as protective, but delicate. Minnie mentions cocooned, which is a good way of putting it.
    The exposure is tricky, but it is excellently chosen to show the reflected sky, The reflected hills, enough details in the shadows and the boat itself.
    Very enjoyable.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:22 p.m.

    Those piercing blue eyes of Meredith are captivating and slightly aggressive. Then the addition of the crane's hook to add a further aggressive touch as a moustache, or even a tusk. is excellent! Including the industrial wall as the background works well and the entire combination creates a compelling image.
    Excellent.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:32 p.m.

    This one I had to see large to really appreciate, (but that is not a bad thing!), then the little details you mention here become apparent and can be enjoyed. We can't see what the guests are eating, but we can see the beautiful scenery and light, which is no doubt adding to the dining experience.
    St. Martin certainly looks like a lovely place to visit.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:36 p.m.

    Yes, I think I prefer this version.
    The lovely warm light on both versions is tremendous, especially with its orange against the blue sky, and add the graceful beauty of the trees and the photo has all it needs. Sometimes too many ingredients can spoil a photo.

  • Members 1082 posts
    Aug. 17, 2026, 9:44 p.m.

    Agreed. I also like the person seated or praying in the pews. The golden jacket fits the scene perfectly and means the person is not thrust into our attention, but is easily discoverable. The person brings the church and the image alive and I believe is a very important part of the images success.

  • Members 1541 posts
    Aug. 18, 2026, 6:33 p.m.

    Hello all,

    I just got home in the past few hours after an intense final week in Brazil and then a gruelingly long journey back home
    (2 hours boat, waiting, 2 hours bus, waiting and queueing, 1 more hour other boat, 1 more hour other bus, waiting and border formalities, 9 hours plane, waiting, another 3,5 hour on other plane, 2 hours road traffic home etc).

    So excuse me for not having participated much.
    I did read most of the comments while in transit and am happy with the level and quality of the interactions.

    I don't have the energy now to add much if anything (and I feel that most images have gotten their fair amount of useful comments).

    But I will start the new thread tomorrow and will be more available for participation in coming weeks.