My first thought was that it’s actually a nice photo, but it somehow lacks contrast.
The rock and the boat are almost the same color.
The boat really ought to stand out against the rock.
In a pinch, you could even use the boat as a bathtub.
A study in balance. The straight lines of he buildings V the silhouetted curves of landscape behind. A narrow tone range that works on highlights v shadows. The mass on the right V the large subject rea on the left.
They all combine into a dawn moment at a specific place.
I agree with your analysis. 2 and 3 are fine macro shots but1 has some magic and story because the bee is airborne, coming or going with pollen attached. The framing of the bee by the petals and the drop down to the stamen are visually appealing. Then there is the watcher, the ant.
Lots to like in this shot while the other two support the details.
But taking a close look at the woman's right hand raises questions for me!
The fingers are much thicker and shorter than usual!
The thumb on the left hand is unusual, too.
What is going on in this photo that makes me have doubts?
This image has been taken by me of my granddaughter in 2018. I have a series of RAW images of her show off. Please stop throwing unsubstantiated accusations around.